Caretaker Defiance Guide,

for Thoughtful Kids

Introduction

A child saying yay in front of a no happy children sign

When is it OK to go against your caretakers? What does it mean to defy them? Sure, a child not doing something healthy at their parents’ request might be defiant, but what about hitting someone who pronounces a word differently from your caretakers? Is that defiance or respect? Is thinking that your caretakers have bad qualities, without them letting you know, defiance or respect? What if a parent asks their child to hurt another child? Is obeying them respectful? Is raising your own kids with less hardship than your parents gave you, defiance or respect? Is admitting someone is right, when your caretakers never admitted you were right, defiance? Is giving up hope that your parents are smart enough to try things a different way, defiance? Perhaps defiance is good sometimes, but when?

This guide is split into different sections to help you decide when you should defy someone:

  Book Chapters